THE HISTORY OF THE STUDY OF MEDIEVAL WEAPONS OF THE 13TH-14TH CC. (ANNIVERSARY AND POLEMICAL ESSAYS)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24852/2587-6112.2020.6.301.315Keywords:
I. L. Izmailov's anniversary, V. Sventoslavsky about the battle of Legnica, , Ya.V. Pilipchuk and the complex of weapons of the medieval Ingush, whether there wereAbstract
The paper features three short essays. The fi rst essay is dedicated to the 60th Anniversary of Doctor of Historical Sciences I. L. Izmailov. The second essay contains a critical review of the version proposed by Polish researcher V. Sventoslavsky concerning the actual use of "combat poison gases" by the Tatar-Mongols in the Battle of Legnica (1241). Based on the information provided by Polish historian of the 15th century Jan Dlugosz, the version has no substantial grounds. The third essay contains an overview of the not always positive experience of characterization by Ukrainian researcher, Doctor of Historical Sciences Ya.V Pilipchuk (Kiev)
of a complex of weapons of the ancestors of the medieval Ingush. A simple list of the known categories of weapons of the Ingush ancestors does not ensure a clear understanding of the process and dynamics of their military development, simplifying the understanding of the complexity of its formation. Ya. V. Pilipchuk, avoiding the demonstration of the historiographical heritage of his predecessors, is also subject to unjustifi ed inaccuracies. For instance, they include claims about the use of "guns and cannons" by Emir Timur in Georgia. All this makes the publications considered by the researcher to be the works of questionable scientifi c quality.
References
Arkheologiia Evraziiskikh stepei (Archaeology of Eurasian Steppes) 5. (in Russian).
Basov, V. I., Nnarozhny, E. I., Tikhonov M., P. 2003. In Narozhnyi, E. I. (ed.). Materialy i issledovaniya po arkheologii Severnogo Kavkaza (Materials and Studies on the Archaeology of the North Caucasus). 2. Armavir: Archaeological Research Centre of Armavir State Pedagogical Institute, 105–111 (in Russian).
Voronin, N. N. 1948. In Voronin, N. N., Karger, M. K., Tikhanova, M. M. (eds.). Istoriia kultury Drevnei Rusi. Domongol’skii period. T. 1. Material’naia kultura (History of the Culture of Ancient Russia. Pre-Mongol Period. Vol. I: Material Culture) Moscow; Leningrad, 439−470 (in Russian).
Gorelik, M. V. 2008. In Vestnik Kabardino-Balkanskoog Instituta gumanitarnykh issledovanii (Bulletin of Kabardino-Balkarian Institute for Humanitarian Studies) 15, 158−189 (in Russian).
Gorelik, M. V. 2011. In Mirgaleev, I. M. (ed.). Zolotoordynskoe nasledie. Materialy Mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii «Politicheskaia i sotsial'no-ekonomicheskaia istoriia Zolotoi Ordy». 29 - 30 marta 2011 g (Heritage of the Golden Horde. Proceedings of the International Scientifi c Conference “Political and Socio-Economic History of the Golden Horde.” March 29-30, 2011.) 2. Kazan: “Foliant” Publ.; Institute of History named after Sh. Mardzhani, Tatarstan Academy of Sciences Publ., 77−89 (in Russian).
Dmitriev, A. V., Narozhny, E. I. 2019. In Bocharov, S. G., Sitdikov, A. G. (ed.). Genuezskaia Gazariia i Zolotaia Orda (The Genoese Gazaria and the Golden Horde) 2. Series: Archaeological Records of Eastern Europe. Kazan; Kishinev: “Stratum Plus” Publ., 599–641 (in Russian).
Druzhinina, I. A. 2017. In Arkheologiia Evraziiskikh stepei (Archaeology of Eurasian Steppes) 5. 99–107 (in Russian).
Druzhinina I. A., Chkhaidze V. N. 2013. In Kozenkova, V. I. (ed.). Ocherki srednevekovoi arkheologg Kavkaza. K 85-letiyu so dnia rozhdeniia V. A. Kuznetsova (Essays on Medieval Archaeology of the Caucasus. To the 85th Anniversary of V. A. Kuznetsov). Moscow: Institute of Archeology of RAS, 74−81 (in Russian).
Sayfetdinova, E. G. (eds.). 2013. Zolotaia Orda: bibliografi cheskii ukazatel’ (Golden Horde: Bibliographic Index) Kazan: Kazan: Institute of History named after Shigabuddin Mardzhani, Tatarstan Academy of Sciences (in Russian).
Kadyrbaev, A. Sh. 2008. In Istoriia i sovremennost’ (History and Contemporaneity) 1, 76−98 (in Russian).
Karger, M. A. 1950. Arkheologicheskie issledovaniia drevnego Kieva (Archaeological Studies of Ancient Kiev). Kiev (Lviv): Academy of Sciences of the Ukrainian SSR (in Russian).
Krupnov, E. I. 1971. Srednevekovaia Ingushetiia (Medieval Ingushetia). Moscow: “Nauka” Publ. (in Russian).
Mayorov, A.V. 2016. In Mirgaleev, I. M., Khautala, R. (eds.). Zolotaya Orda v mirovoi istorii (The Golden Horde in world history). Kazan: Institute of History named after Shigabuddin Mardzhani, Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, 89−113 (in Russian).
Mamaev, R. Kh. 2017. In Vestnik Akademii nauk Chechenskoi Respubliki ( Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of the Chechen Republic) 36 (3), 54−59 (in Russian).
Mamaev, R. Kh. 2019. In Vestnik Akademii nauk Chechenskoi Respubliki ( Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of the Chechen Republic) 47 (7), 71−75 (in Russian).
Mamaev, R. Kh. 2016. In Mamaev, Kh. M. (ed.). Izuchenie i sokhranenie arkheologicheskogo naslediia narodov Kavkaza. XXIX «Krupnovskie chteniya» po arkheologii Severnogo Kavkaza» (Study and preservation of archaeological heritage of the peoples of Caucasus. The XXIX-th Krupnov’s reading. Krupnov Readings on the Archaeology of the North Caucasus). Grozny: Chechen State University, 229−230 (in Russian).
Mamaev, R. Kh. 2013. In Vestnik Akademii nauk Chechenskoi Respubliki ( Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of the Chechen Republic) 20 (3), 74−84 (in Russian).
Mamaev, Kh. M., Mamaev, R. Kh. 2011. In Vestnik Akademii nauk Chechenskoi Respubliki ( Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of the Chechen Republic) 14 (1), 124−128 (in Russian).
Mamaev, R. Kh., Mamaeva, R. A., Mamaev, Kh. M. 2016. In Kutuev, R. A.(ed.). In Nauka i molodezh (Science and Youth). Grozny: Chechen Sate University, 333−336 (in Russian).
Mamaev, Kh. M., Mamaev, R. Kh., Narozhny, E. I. 2016. In Vestnik Akademii nauk Chechenskoi Respubliki ( Bulletin of the Academy of Sciences of the Chechen Republic) 16(1), 333−336 (in Russian).
Mamaev, Kh. M., Chakhkiev, D. Yu. 1983. In Vinogradov, V. B. (ed.). Khoziaistvo i khoziaistvennii byt (Economy and Economic Life). Grozny, 68−78 (in Russian).
Mamaev, Kh. M., Chakhkiev, D. Yu., Dautova, R. A. 1983. In Vinogradov, V. B. (ed.). Novye arkheologicheskie materialy po srednevekovoi istorii Checheno-Ingushetii (New Archaeological Materials on the Medieval History of Chechen-Ingushetia). Grozny: TINIEST, 44−80 (in Russian).
Muzhahoev, M. B. Narozhnyi, E. I., Chakhkiev, D. Y. 2017. In Arkheologiia Evraziiskikh stepei (Archaeology of Eurasian Steppes) 5. 77–185 (in Russian).
Narozhny, V. E. 2012. Naselenie vysokogornoi Ingushetii v XIII-XV vekakh (Population of High-Mountain Ingushetia in the 13th-15th Centuries) Thesis of Diss. of the Candidate of Historical Sciences. Vladikavkaz: North Ossetian state University (in Russian).
Narozhny, V. E., Narozhny, E. I. 2009. In Gorbenko, A. А. (ed.). Dialog gorodskoi i stepnoi kul'tur na Evraziiskom prostranstve. (Dialogue of the Urban and Steppe Cultures in the Eurasian Space). Series:Antiquities of the Don 10. Azov: Azov Historical-Archaeological and Palaeontological Museum-Reserve Publ., 373–387 (in Russian).
Narozhny, V. E., Narozhny, E. I. 2012. In Povolzhskaia arkheologiia (Volga River Region Archaeology) (2), 173–183 (in Russian).
Narozhny, V. E., Narozhny, E. I. 2013. In. Kashuba, M. T., Skakov, A. Yu. (eds.). Tret'ia Abhazskaia mezhdunarodnaia arkheologicheskaia konferentsiia: Problemy drevnei i srednevekovoi arkheologii Kavkaza (The Third Abkhazian International Archaeological Conference "Issues of the Ancient and Medieval Archaeology of the Caucasus). Sukhumi: IIMK RAS; Abkhaz Institute for Humanitarian Research named
after D. I. Gulia ANA; RUP "Dom Pechati" Publ., 321−324 (in Russian).
Narozhny, V. E., Narozhny, E. I., Chakhkiev, D. Yu. 2017. In Arkheologiia Evraziiskikh stepei (Archaeology of Eurasian Steppes) 5. 167–176 (in Russian).
Narozhny, E. I. 2003. In Evglevskii, A. V. (ed.-in-chief). Stepi Evropy v epokhu srednevekov’ia (Steppes of Europe in the Middle Ages) 3. Polovetsko-zolotoordynskoe vremia (The Cuman-Golden Horde Period). Donetsk: Donetsk National University, 245–274 (in Russian).
Narozhny, E. I. 2010. In Arkheologicheskii zurnal (Archaeological Journal) III-IV, 94−95 (in Russian).
Narozhny, E. I. 2011. In Mirgaleev, I. M. (ed.). Voennoe delo Zolotoi Ordy. Problemy i perspektivy izucheniia (Military Affairs of the Golden Horde. Study Issues and Prospects). Kazan: Institute of History named after Sh. Mardzhani, Tatarstan Academy of Sciences Publ., 82−85 (in Russian).
Narozhny, E. I. 2019. In Gadzhiev, M. S. (ed.). Arkheologicheskie raskopki na Severnom Kavkaze. Sbornik izbrannykh nauchnykh rabot S.B. Burkova (Archaeological Excavations in the North Caucasus. Collection of Selected Scientifi c Works by S. B. Burkov). Makhachkala: “Mavraev” Publ, 371−393 (in Russian).
Narozhny, E. I., Narozhny, V. E., Chakhkiev, D. Yu. 2005. In Narozhnyi, E. I. (ed.). Materialy i issledovaniya po arkheologii Severnogo Kavkaza (Materials and Studies on the Archaeology of the North Caucasus). 5. Armavir: International Academy of Sciences, 291−304 (in Russian).
Narozhny, E. I., Chakhkiev, D. Yu. 2003 In Vinogradov, V. B., Narozhnyi, E. I. (ed.). Desiatye chteniia po arkheologii Srednei Kubani (Tenth Readings on the Archaeology of the Middle Kuban). Armavir: Archaeological Research Centre of Armavir State Pedagogical Institute, 42-43 (in Russian).
Narozhny, E. I., Chakhkiev, D. Yu. 2003. In Narozhnyi, E. I. (ed.). Materialy i issledovaniya po arkheologii Severnogo Kavkaza (Materials and Studies on the Archaeology of the North Caucasus). 2. Armavir: Archaeological Research Centre of Armavir State Pedagogical Institute, 126–153 (in Russian).
Narozhny, E. I., Chakhkiev, D. Yu. 2010. In Narozhnyi, E. I. (ed.). Materialy i issledovaniya po arkheologii Severnogo Kavkaza (Materials and Studies on the Archaeology of the North Caucasus) 10. Armavir: Archaeological Research Centre of Armavir State Pedagogical Institute, 237−239 (in Russian).
Orlov, R. S., Motsya, A. P., Pokas, P. M. 1985. In Tolochko, P. P. (ed.). Zemli Yuzhnoi Rusi IX-XIV vv. (Southern Russian Lands in the 9th-14th cc.). Kiev: “Naukova dumka” Publ., 41−60 (in Russian).
Pashuto, V. T. 1977. In Tikhvinskii, S. L. (ed.).Tataro-mongoly v Azii i Evrope (Tatar-Mongols in Asia and Europe) Moscow: “Nauka" Publ., 210−227 (in Russian).
Pilipchuk, Ya. V. 2013. In Kliashtornyi, S. G., Ivanov, V.A., Zagidullin, I.K. Tiurkskie kochevniki Evrazii (kimaki, kipchaki, polovtsy …) (Turkic Nomads of Eurasia (Kimeks, Kipchaks, Cumans...)). Kazan: Ikhlas Publ., 187−209 (in Russian).
Pilipchuk, Y. V. 2011. In Vestnik KazNPU (Bulletin of the Kazakh National Pedagogical University named after Abai. Series: Historical and socio-political Sciences. Series: Historical and Socio-Political Sciences) 4 (31), 12−17 (in Russian).
Pilipchuk, Ya. V. 2012. In Evglevskii, A. V. (ed.-in-chief). Stepi Evropy v epokhu srednevekov’ia (Steppes of Europe in the Middle Ages). 10. Polovetskoe vremia (Polovtsian Time). Donetsk: Donetsk National University, 337–346 (in Russian).
Pilipchuk, Ya. V. 2012. In Vestnik KazNPU (Bulletin of the Kazakh National Pedagogical University named after Abai. Series: Historical and Socio-Political Sciences. Series: Historical and Socio-Political Sciences) 4 (35), 26−31 (in Russian).
Pilipchuk ,Ya. V. 2016. In Vestnik KazNPU (Bulletin of the Kazakh National Pedagogical University named after Abai. Series: Historical and Socio-Political Sciences. Series: Historical and Socio-Political Sciences). 4(5371-1), 58−65 (in Russian).
Pilipchuk, Ya. V. 2019. In Amirani. 32, 129−146 (in Russian).
Rezul’taty radiouglerodnykh datirovok. Zakliuchenie po rezul'tatam dendrokhronologicheskogo issledovaniia (Radiocarbon Dating Results. Conclusion on the Results of Dendrochronological Studies in2015) Available at: http://ing-arheologiya.ru/index.php/nauka/85-otchet-po-dendro-rabotam-2015-g (Accessed 05.12.2020) (in Russian).
Savenko, S. N. 2020. In Narozhnyi, E. I. (ed.). Materialy i issledovaniya po arkheologii Severnogo Kavkaza (Materials and Studies on the Archaeology of the North Caucasus). 18. Armavir: Archaeological Research Centre of Armavir State Pedagogical Institute, 364−377 (in Russian).
Salnikov, A. V. 2017. In Teoriia I praktika arheologicheskikh issledovaniy (Theory and practice of archaeological research) 19 (3), 91−106. DOI: https://doi.org/10.14258/tpai(2017)3(19).-06 (in Russian).
Svetoslavsky, V. 1998. In Voennaia arkheologiia. Oruzhie i voennoe delo v istoricheskoi i sotsial'noi perspective (Military Archaeology. Armament and Military Art in the Historical and Social Perspective). Saint Petersburg: The State Hermitage Museum, 295–297 (in Russian).
Svetoslavsky, V. 2012. In Mason, V. I. (ed.). Zapiski Vostochnogo ondeleniia Russkogo arkheologicheskogo obshchestva (Notes of the Eastern Branch of the Russian Archaeological Society) 1 (XXVI). Saint-Petersburg: Petersburg Oriental studies, 393−379 (in Russian).
Studenetskaya, E. N. 1989. Odezhda narodov Severnogo Kavkaza. XVIII-XX vv. (Clothing of the Peoples of the North Caucasus. 18th-20th cc.). Moscow: “Nauka” Publ. (in Russian).
Tarabanov, V. A. 1984. In Anfi mov, N. V., Outlev, P. U. (eds.). Voprosy arkheologii Adygei (Issues of Archaeology of Adygea). Maykop, 164–172 (in Russian).
Timokhin, D. M., Tishin, V. V. 2020. In Istoriia, arkheologiia i etnografi ia Kavkaza (History, Archaeology and Ethnography of the Caucasus) Vol. 16, No. 1, 2020, Pp. 210-226. DOI: https://doi.org/10.32653/CH161210-226 (in Russian).
Chakhkiev, D. Yu., Narozhny, E. I. 1990. In Khudiakov, Yu. S. (ed.). Voennoe delo drevnego i srednevekovogo naseleniia Severnoi i Tsentral'noi Azii (Military Art of the Ancient and Medieval Population of Northern and Central Asia). Novosibirsk: Novosibirsk State University, 129−141 (in Russian).
Chakhkiev, D. Y. 1988. In Muzhahoev, M. B. (ed.). Novye materialy po arkheologii i etnografi i Checheno-Ingushetii (New Materials on the Archaeology and Ethnography of the Chechen-Ingush Republic). Grozny: Checheno-Ingushskoe knizhnoe izdatel'stvo Publ., 85−95 (in Russian).
Chakhkiev, D. Yu. 2019. Oruzhie i voprosy voennogo iskusstva pozdnesrednevekovykh ingushei i chechentsev (ХIII-ХVIII vv.). (Weapons and Issues of Military Art of the Late Medieval Ingush and Chechens (13-18 centuries). Magas (in Russian).
Chakhkiev D. Yu., Golovanova S. A., Narozhny E. I. 1986. In Vinogradov, V. B. (ed.). Problemy khronologii pogrebal'nykh pamiatnikov Checheno-Ingushetii (Issues of of Chronology of the Funerary Monuments of Chechen-Ingushetia). Grozny: Checheno-Ingushskoe knizhnoe izdatel'stvo Publ., 70−80 (in Russian).
Chakhkiev, D. Yu., Narozhny, E. I. 2002. In Nauchnyi vestnik Ingushskogo gosuniversiteta (Scientifi c Bulletin of the Ingush State University) 1, 4−8 (in Russian).
Shkolyar,. S. A. 1980. Kitaiskaia doognestrel'naia artilleriua (Materialy i issledovaniua) (Chinese Pre-Fire Artillery (Materials and Studies). Moscow: “Nauka: Publ. (in Russian).
Dąbrowska, E. 1958. In Archeologia. VIII, Z.1, 122−167 (in Polish).
Mamaev R.Kh. 2019.In The European Proceedings of Social & Behavioural Sciences EpSBS, 2115-2119 (in English).
Tsurtsumia, M. 2015. In Acta Militaria Mediaevalia. XI. 159−172 (in English).
Tsurtsumia, M. 2018. In Acta Militaria Mediaevalia. 14, 87−114 (in English) .
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2020 E. I. Narozhny
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
